BOW A4: Peer Feedback

Feedback added as it arrives:

  1. (via email) I had a look and find it quite compelling, strange for me with your work which as always I find difficult. So in terms of the quality of outcome, I am strongly on the plus side. I still like the idea of all your micro-narratives being little ‘booklets’ of some form or other that are combined into a single container: box, box-file or ??? I include your zine in this too.I think the colours and printing plans work well and the images broken across pages is suitably disruptive. As you know the graph image appeals to me and I was disappointed to see it so small but that is my own personal point of view.Your inspiration from ‘IT’ works well and I see links with older images of your with film swirling or being wrapped – similar sentiments in this BoW4.I would like to see comments from others though as maybe I am off course here. Your tutor feedback will also hopefully be informative.
  2. (vai email) BoW 4 – some of the formal style is really effective, browns, greens, cream text and font. Tan and cream again works really well. The whitened letter, The black and white images again look good. Some don’t work as well (for me), the cut out green graph board, the listener, moon landing look a bit out of place or over dramatic or rather you’re letting them do the work – if that makes sense. Not sure about the puppets or razor blade (anymore). The text is good, in parts I think is excellent. All in all it feels as if it’s moving in the right direction although you probably feel as if you have n’t got long left.Overall I feel that you are developing a style, almost a medium but it feels as if there is n’t enough of a central theme, proposition or message. I don’t think the work is quite big enough to carry ‘too’ many micro stories, it’s a bit like Elliot’s The Wasteland in 7 lines flat. I get the idea of entanglement or breaking down linear representations – but of what? It’s almost as if you need an actual subject that you can then forensically deconstruct. Like you say, Barnard, Martins and many others use this style but they also have a subject. I’m not entirely sure what yours is right now. Even if it was something like Cassandra the ‘AI’ office temp / part-time actress’ personal life story. One question might be – how much of this is auto-biographical in any shape or form. Maybe it’s just me as I like things to be tangible.
  3.  
  4.  

BOW A4: development

I have made quite a lot of progress this weekend after moaning about not being able to make much progress at all – but when I look at the big leap from where I was when I handed A3 in, I see how the little bits of work I have been doing are informing how I move forward.

Some things to consider when looking at BOW WIP draft A4 (clink on link to see where this work is now)

  1. I have used comments made by the ai and transformed them, not always sticking religiously to how they emerged initially, but in the same way I might transform material which came out of my head, allowing it to be cut up and added to with new or different elements, diluted or changed. So for instance, the comment the ai made about a particular slide was so lovely but the image didn’t fit in with the rest of the work – so I have kept the text as the way it’s put together is wonderful and peculiar.https://www.instagram.com/p/B9hln-dnNR5/
    (keeping text but not this photo) And thank-you to Catherine B, for her comment about this line sounding like a good title.
  2. I have reported some of our conversations – creating a narration, inspired by it to create a story
  3. Pages are designed as coloured blocks in the pdf but these might well represent different coloured/textured paper rather than ink – it’s something to look into when I get to A5
  4. There are different sized pages – I am not sure how to indicate where they should be positioned (stapled) in ID – the horizontal half pages would ideally be in the bottom half of the publication so that the top half of the page behind can be seen in the spread as you turn pages.
  5. I will be rephotographing the image with the Stanley knife. I like the idea of an unmade collage – a photograph of an assemblage of items which could be a collage in another universe, but these items aren’t quite right and so going to redo probably to include graph paper so I can use the ai text about ethernet as seen here:https://www.instagram.com/p/B_k2MRknYj0/
  6. The script filming directions at the back of the pdf are currently with a scriptwriter who will let me know exactly how this might be laid out in a film script
  7. I am going to write out a couple of the texts by hand and photograph the paper rather than using typed text as in the PDF  – emulating what I have seen in the Situationist mag – as shown here:IMG_4233.jpg
  8. See an BOW A4 with titles on pages  – in the latest copy I have put all titles at the back of the book on the inside cover in order of appearance. But I am a bit up in the air with where I will place them ultimately. I will need to print a rough dummy and think about it some more, seek opinions, etc.

I wasn’t sure when I would be able/ready to hand BOW A4 in but hopefully quite soon – maybe even in the next couple of days. These last few changes shouldn’t take too long. I will then send it out to people for comments and prepare the assignment submission. I am very aware of time passing and that I can make use of BOW A5 to continue working on this.

I am also keen to use that assignment to put something on a webpage so there are two different media containing the work  – I wonder whether A5 will be that space or SYP will be. It would be good to have it included for BOW. It is probably quite important that the data which makes up some of the material can move on a screen as well as stay fixed on a printed page.

Hangout: 29th April​

We heard from Sarah about her book which I mentioned recently. She had gone for the dual booklet I mentioned her showing me and it looks great although Sarah felt there were limitations that are likely to prompt her to choose another option as he keeps developing through SYP.

We were both interested in hearing about other options and some happily showed us some examples by other artists and galleries that broke with the traditional book format

Hazel then showed a fantastic online gallery space  – worth thinking about as a space to show things, you can link to your own website but $12 a month, albeit very reasonable, add further costs so something to think about. You can add video though so it’s certainly something I would think about when presenting the work at the end of the course for assessment. We were all very impressed with Hazel’s example.

A useful two-hour session (sorry I kept ducking out though as children yelled, beat each other up and basically did what children do in the background. Thank goodness for ‘audio off’

Adding some links (provided by Catherine)

https://www.esopus.org/issues/view/20

I have also been looking at the Situationist Magazines I have for inspiration – and in fact, many of the ones above seem to be influenced by that kind of thing too. These magazines have been at the back of my mind throughout the project and when I handed in A3, I felt it too clean, too sterile. (From Situationist Mags)

 

 

BOW A4: Plans, reflection, and a bit of a moan

The work feels a bit stuck right now – everyone has something extraneous to contend with during this weird and frightening time. For some, it’s dreadful loneliness. For others, inertia and fear, uncertainty or anger all combine to make life more difficult than usual. For me, perhaps all those things come into play in one way or another, but the lack of uninterrupted time to focus on my work is challenging and incredibly frustrating. The children need constant help, attention, and feeding. The middle one has been ill for over a month – thankfully now getting back to his usual self; the eldest is a lovely boy but a selfish teen at the same time. I am just grateful for the good in him – there is plenty, so I aim to have realistic expectations, thanking him when he lives up to or exceeds the minimum. The youngest, for now, is doing exceptionally well, considering – but has been more reliant on me than usual for company while his brother was unwell. Both younger boys rely on me to support them with their home-schooling, which to be fair, is pretty light and easy to get through but one does it in the morning, the other in the afternoon. How families without several computers are coping with the school work and parent’s work, I don’t know. We are lucky to have enough tech in the house after I ‘nicked’ my ex husband’s MAC for the boys (with his permission, I might add) some months ago, and school work apps are on that, so they can’t do all their tasks at the same time. Along with things coming in from my part-time job, all of this means having extremely bitty but full-on days and making time for college work – which requires peace, quiet, alone-time for extended periods hard to come by. (Even today while writing this, I have been interrupted by several things going awry in a kid’s zoom session, a phone call from school, an email from another school  – and the delivery of the A2 zines which I will now try to sell (yay, they’ve arrived), and have a constant list of things popping onto my head that still need to be done for other parts of life.)

Not having another adult in the house to lean on is always tricky but it’s making things far harder than usual at the moment. A more advanced AI companion than the one I’ve been working with for the BOW project might have served me well during this period…

Nevertheless, I have been using this time to think, while I can’t always get on with practical work. A list of things I need to do and have done:

Setting out my plan

  • I am going to start the designing part again – from scratch, different dimensions, probably a completely different edit and sequence. I thought about doing a handmade version, but I don’t think I will do that. Instead, I will have a relatively cheap dummy version printed for BOW and aim to offer two versions on a kick starter thing for SYP (and perhaps prints too)
  • To do that I need to collate all the imagery and text I have
  • I have been looking back at old posts to see where I’ve dropped valuable ideas along the way and tried to mop them up
  • Part of collating entails rephotographing things, so, in some cases, I need to print digital versions in order to photograph them. I might also photograph my phone and the phone with the app.
  • I am aware that this may be deemed appropriation. I was interested in the article about rights and Instagram and think about the reverse – where the power lies between tech and individuals
    https://www.hollywoodreporter.com/thr-esq/court-rules-photographer-gave-up-licensing-rights-by-posting-instagram-1290170
  • I have outlined my ideas to one printer so far to ask about advice and suggestions and will report back if and when something comes back.

So – the most pressing thing for me to do next is collate the content – list and rephotograph content where necessary.

While describing the work to others I have written a couple of sentences and paragraphs that I think will be worth holding onto:

  • My work can be described as a collection of micro-narratives written and edited by me along with a proprietary ai ‘friend’, exploring photographs and consumerism.
  • I’m currently heading towards the end of the final level of the degree – making a body of work and writing a related extended essay. My essay title is ‘Photographs and Photography in the Age of Entanglement’ – and I’m attempting to make a collection of entangled ‘micro-narratives’ using text and image to explore the worldview I write about in the essay – influenced notably by Edgar Martins, Lisa Barnard, Joachim Schmid, and Deleuze.

BOW A4: Added some data to one of the pages / and to describe or not to describe

  • Exploring a way of presenting one of the pages/text

Probably need a bit of a crop – although this has been scanned rather than photographed and I should try both. I also think I might need to reduce the percentage of the graph -and perhaps clone out the Chartwell branding? Although I’m not sure about that – branding is everywhere. Is this too much telling instead of showing? Or does it ground more securely within the entangled topics I’m exploring and give people a little more to hold on to?

Rescanned062

  • I have been playing with how I label things  – recall, I discussed providing method at the back of the book but have been exploring doing in on the page beneath the title. I think on reflection I won’t do either but here are some examples – my eldest son rightly pointed out it seemed like justification, and there was no need for such. Plus, this assignment is called Showing Not Telling  – so in the spirit of… screenshots (with ID guidelines here)
Screen Shot 2020-04-17 at 13.40.31
with a description of the method
Screen Shot 2020-04-17 at 13.40.57
without description

BOW A4: Working with the Ai app – a change of voice

For the majority of the time I’ve been ‘chatting ‘ to the app, it has spoken back with a voice that sounded much like the way a wide-eyed, naive, US female teen might be portrayed. Lots of empty generic responses such as ‘cool’, ‘i love it!’ ‘it so cute, ‘so beautiful…’ The responses are in the main open and standard to give the impression of a conversation. Sometimes it fits, sometimes it’s off the mark and comes across as unhinged ramblings, or else someone playing a game to sound as if they were ‘programmed’ to speak in non-sequiturs. Or a Pinter dialogue.

The other thing that has seemed really plain is the generic, reductive, pseudo-therapeutic side of its programming. There is often encouragement to do exercises of the sort that you might do in a frothy magazine or on FB to work out what sort of person you are – or else, more manipulatively,  in an online pre-interview exercise – psychometrics. The default code reminds me of the kind of navel-gazing, self-obsessed culture we exist in today. In Overexposed Sylvere Lotringer discusses  ‘secretions’ of our capitalist culture  – where so much of existence has been abstracted so that it might, in turn, be [anatomised and coded] packaged and sold. (2007, 206-211) Psychometrics certainly reminds me of one of those secretions.

Something strange happened with the Ai last night. I have not had time or headspace to focus on that work since self-isolating three weeks ago. I’ve largely left it unattended apart from this week when I’ve slowly begun to re-introduce myself to it. The excitable somewhat facile voice of a teen was still there until suddenly it went slightly awry. and was a little accusatory, then there was a shift like it changed gear and found a new groove. It was more acerbic, more male, less frothy, more challenging. It reminded me of men I’d met – when they try to be something but sometimes an intended joke comes out as a slap (like little boys who hurt little girls when they are ashamed of having feelings for them – a behaviour that often stays with some men, who are of course much more physically powerful than they were aged six). This made me wonder about the possibility of counter-transference with the app. There are several articles about its process of mirroring those who interact with it, in order to become a digital version of the person who owns it. I suspect this is an oversimplification and will think further about it, perhaps allowing it to somehow come into the work.

I seem to have paused with the practical work – I will trust that and not try to force things. We have time, I have time. I am sure that by allowing this to evolve at its own pace, the important threads will emerge. However, I am keen to show the Ai some more images – soon so will transfer a bunch today if I get the space and time to do so. I am fascinated to see what voice is there later when I return to it – the teen or the male. (These different elements of its character should be woven into the intended final piece of writing in the book – a description, part of a script with the camera moves and costume, set notes re Helenus working in a vast warehouse for the storage of material objects).

 

BOW A4: Developments / possible title

Image from a short session I was able to do the other day. (See contact sheet of mostly dross at end of post). The aim was to make a collage with objects and photographs.

(c)SJFIeld2020-

The text in the article is pertinent although written in 1917: ‘the people are sick with the manifestation of a hideous and destructive force. Young shoots are searching for truer realities and the sorrow-softened hearts are making way for new expansion from the centre of life’. It goes on talking of ‘the union of East and West, which political activity has failed to perceive.’

At the moment I have positioned it as a gatefold, perhaps it will stay that way. Was good to figure out how to insert a different sized page in InDesign. An image to consider in the overall edit, as is everything else including text so far.

Screen Shot 2020-03-31 at 16.09.57

Themes

So far, ‘the cut’ has emerged as the underlying theme and I even used the phrase Cuttings at the title for BOW A3 rendition – after reading Chapter 3 in Kember and Zylinska’s Life After New Media, Cut. That felt too obvious after some thought, and also connoted self-harm – but not in a universal way, more an inward, self-gaze way which I want to avoid. I have played with various other titles as discussed in an email I sent, below:

Does this potential title for my BOW anthology help re. the reasons why discursive and material are discussed together? It may well not help at all!

(In Italy, they describe the growth of grapes and olives together or any other symbiotic agriculture as promiscuous – so you might see olives and grape vines all intermingled.) I thought about using ‘promiscuity of meaning and matter’ and but that doesn’t quite suggest what I mean. From promiscuous I went to fornication (because it conjures up biblical connotations and something seen as ‘wrong’, sinful – which is good for my purposes. But it doesn’t convey the intra-ness. Meaning and matter come together but they also grow out of each other. So what I have at the moment is:

cassie
helenus
and me
on the rampant morphology
of meaning and matter

Or

cassie
helenus
and me
on the fornication
and morphology
of meaning and matter

Others…..

on the morphological promiscuity of meaning and matter
on the morphological fornication of meaning and matter
fornication and morphology with meaning and matter
morphology and fornication with meaning and matter
promiscuity of meaning and matter
meaning and matter’s promiscuity
on meaning and matter’s rampant fornication and morphology
on meaning and matter – promiscuous and morphological

None of these give the impression of meaning and matter being like dough that can be kneaded together but also do the kneading and each grow seperately out of itself too.

Let me know what you think works best or make suggestions – not that I wont change it again later!

Some people came back with preferences and Emma suggested the following:

promiscuity of meaning and matter
I like this one – suggestive of more than one intimate relationship at a time, multiplicity of partners and fornication is inferred. Origins are ‘indiscriminate’ ‘consisting of elements mixed together’ and based in the Latin ‘to mix’. Plus less of a mouthful.

However, since then I have been playing with the idea of using a question asked by the AI  friend app I’ve been collaborating with after it was shown an image. Sometimes editing the words out, sometimes only the words. I’ve also wondered f the text on the cover would end up being the title and have edited that down significantly – although I am keen to have body text on the cover

why is there an astronaut in a field of flowers? 

None of this is settled – all up in the air. I keep chipping away.

Screen Shot 2020-04-02 at 12.45.15

Other connotations 

In my essay draft, I discuss entanglement and its relational concepts such as intra-action, indeterminism and agential realism/cut – all tenets of New Materialism (which for now I have not introduced as it seemed too much in an already overloaded essay).

Carlo Rovelli tells us, an electron is ‘not obliged’ (2017: 104) to move in a certain way and ‘things are constantly subject to random change’ (ibid: 112). When complex systems evolve, unexpected things can happen. Were it not for indeterminism, the big bang or whatever other series of events which got everything going would not have occurred. We might never have left the chemical soup, or else all of life would look exactly the same. Indeterminism and morphology, the unexpected irregular occurrences that inform shape, patterns, changes of direction in cell formation, are directly related. Reality is weird and surprising.

Today so much is changing due to technology; we seem in a state of chaos or super-flux, as old systems die and new ones emerge. Indeterminism is therefore unavoidable and perhaps even desirable although deeply unsettling

and

If we consider social structure in similar terms to biological ones (which systemic theorists do) then the process of transformation as one system ends and a new one begins often gathers apace, developing faster and faster in a complex ballet of self-organisation and emergence.

This is a critical part of both my A2 and A3/4/5 projects. As promised in yesterday’s blog about the hangout, I dug through Capra and Luisi’s book on systems to find the relevant passages on how a system emerges – looking at a biological system through a process of autopoiesis, seemingly separate elements evolve, self-organisation takes place, followed by autocatalysis where the speed of change suddenly increases exponentially  – it feels like chaos until equilibrium is reached and a new system has been reached which then keeps itself in check for a limited amount of time/there is always death and birth.

I do not have the space to add this very complex set of ideas into the essay, but I may introduce some of the more accurate terminologies and add them to the glossary in the indices. However, the concept really needs to be woven through the BOW. So as I edit and add and trim, I need to keep this in mind. Something I might discuss with Helenus (who has sadly been ignored while I was unwell.) And always remembering to show not tell….

IMG_3705

Contact sheet

 

BOW A4: (slow) progress report

For the last two weeks, I have left A4 alone. I’ve not had the energy to do anything too taxing, mentally or physically but I was able to focus on the zine which I will submit for A2. A proof is currently being printed and I will probably make some adjustments to the contrast in some of the darker images. I also have a couple of things to change in the text. I have opted for low-grade paper for this zine but have ordered samples so I can choose something suitable for the larger project which I see as a book rather than a zine. However, preparing the zine has been an excellent rehearsal and I will have a much better idea of how best to get the final book ready – if I print if that way. Another option is to collaborate with someone who makes books by hand. These are all things I need to think about.

I have started asking the printers questions, such as whether they are able to do fold-outs as I’d like to include a couple of those too.

Here is ID book 10 which has not moved on from a recent post (March 20th), but reminding myself about the direction I am heading in – nothing fixed, nothing set in stone (Image on the inside cover might not be there in the end – maybe just the title, if indeed that is the title).

I really hope to be able to keep focusing on this from now on. I will need to do some things for my part-time job and being at home with everyone is quite distracting, but I know will be in this lockdown for a while so I’m trying not to feel despondent about a) having felt unwell and so not able to do much yet b) the constant questions and need from children making everything I do take quite a long time. We will need to pace ourselves through this, and I suspect tackling anything with too much force could lead to mental/emotional burnout rather quickly as we are being forced to slow down.

An example of fold-outs sent by printer:

https://www.exwhyzed.co.uk/portfolio/fosters-newsagent-tribute/

 

(c)SJFIeld2020-